Jewish America — Martin E. Marty

Go to www.jewishdatabank.org to consult the National Jewish Population's latest, much-publicized survey and you will have access to the same data Sightings has

By Martin E. Marty|September 15, 2003

Go to www.jewishdatabank.org to consult the National Jewish Population's latest, much-publicized survey and you will have access to the same data Sightings has. The United Jewish Communities people, who count many Jewish federations under their umbrella, made the decennial assessment. The 1990 survey revealed trends that surprised and shocked Jews and non-Jews alike; the 2000 measuring, since it reports only moderate change, evokes less consternation, but the trends remain clear. Each time the pollsters measure there are: fewer Jews (down five percent in a decade); older Jews (by five years for a current average of 42); fewer practicing where national population growth spurts most (the 22 percent of all American Jews who live in the Western U.S. are most relaxed about their Judaism); more marrying later and having fewer children; more "intermarrying" -- up four percent to 47 percent. Where Jews marry non-Jews, only one-third bring up their children as Jews, while 96 percent of Jewish couples raise their children Jewish. And Jews remain denominationalized: four out of ten belong to Reform congregations, one out of three adheres to Conservatism, and one in five observes within Orthodoxy.

There has to be some good news for Jews in such a survey, and there is. While most Orthodox children were long sent to yeshivas, more non-Orthodox are patronizing Jewish day schools -- though after-school and weekend-schooling numbers are declining. Clearly, the best news is that those who identify with Judaism and Jewish institutions evidently care more about being Jewish than before. The big question: can this caring be passed on to thinning generations?

One problem in all the measuring is: who is a Jew? The religious and ethnic tie is stronger in Judaism than in most other groups, so the definition has to be a bit fuzzy, but the Survey people have found ways to use the same standard decade by decade, so comparisons are valid across time.

Sightings pays attention to religion in public life, which means that Jews loom large in all scoping of the religious scene. Draw a pie-chart to graph American preferences and allegiances and Jews show up in only a sliver, slightly over two percent of the total. I like to remind those who do not understand Jewish concern with numerical decline -- never mind the decline in theology, tradition, history, community, sentiment, and affection -- that there are fewer Jews in the whole world than there are Southern Baptists in the U.S. alone.

Non-Jews, who care intrinsically about Jews and Judaism, also have extrinsic reasons to be concerned about loss of numbers, identity, meaning, and purpose in the Jewish community. Civic-mindedness and philanthropy directed to general-public causes is high: check the membership of boards of and donors to your art museum, symphony, opera, human welfare organizations, higher academies, and more, and you will see how influential beyond numbers Jews are. (A Lutheran, I like to point out that there are far more Lutherans than Jews in the U.S. If you are not Lutheran or close to a Lutheran: name one!)

Again, the good news: Jews who care about Judaism, care more. 

 

Author, Martin E. Marty, is the Fairfax M. Cone Distinguished Service Professor Emeritus of the History of Modern Christianity at the University of Chicago Divinity School. His biography, publications, and contact information can be found at www.memarty.com